We continue this most-compelling series with quarterbacks and running backs.
Running Backs
2011 starter: Arian Foster
2011 relevant depth: Ben Tate, Derrick Ward
2012 starter: Arian Foster
2012 likely depth: Ben Tate, Justin Forsett
Obviously the top two will remain, as Foster and Tate are arguably the best 1-2 RB punch in the NFL. I am actually kind of excited about the addition of Justin Forsett as the number three. I didn’t think much of Ward, at least for his on-field results. Several players have said he is phenomenal in the locker room, but all I have to go by is what a sensitive whiner he was on Twitter. So if that’s not fair to say, then I guess it’s not fair, but I wasn’t a fan.
Call me crazy, but I think Forsett is not only an upgrade over Ward, but probably a significant upgrade. He’s only 26, and is already accustomed to the Texans’ zone blocking scheme, not to mention his success catching the ball out of the backfield.
Verdict: 2012 group is superior with the addition of Forsett.
Quarterbacks
2011 starter: Matt Schaub
2011 relevant depth: Matt Leinart, TJ Yates
2012 starter: Matt Schaub
2012 likely depth: TJ Yates, John Beck
I’d say I’ve heard a pretty even split amongst Texans fans who aren’t overly concerned about Schaub’s foot injury, and those who think there’s a serious problem lurking there. I am concerned, especially since so much of Schaub’s game is pivoting on that foot in the play-action passes. That said, I’m so not in the camp of people that think he is injury prone.
Compared to last year’s group, I have to give the potential edge to the 2012 set of QBs. You had Schaub, a rookie in Yates who nobody expected to ever see the field, and Leinart who – and I cannot be convinced otherwise – was a nothing before coming to Houston and was never going to be anything but after. Now you have Schaub, Yates with a bit more seasoning, and Beck, who I would still take over Matt Leinart. I do not think Case Keenum is going to make the team, but he certainly seems like a likely candidate for the practice squad. I just think Kubiak is going to want a guy who is familiar with the system, and a little older, both of which fit when it comes to Beck.
Verdict: The saddest part of losing Leinart was that it didn’t give enough time for Rivers’ nickname of “Floaties” to set in. I’ll take the 2012 guys.

Jun 17, 2012 at 11:07:21
Well said Sir!!
Jul 2, 2012 at 17:21:01
I think Keenum will make the team