Lamont (via Facebook) asks: What would it take for the Texans to negotiate with Dr. Death aka Al Davis for Darren McFadden or sign L. Tomlinson or or Chester Taylor?
LaDanian Tomlinson is not a big guy, but he has proven to be a very effective short-yardage back. If he were to come to Houston for a home-state discount - and MOST IMPORTANT, understood his role and didn’t complain about it - I would be open to the idea. But if he wants to be THE guy, NO. If he wants a big contract (which someone will give him), then NO. But again, he was an effective short-yardage back on one of the few teams who was worse at run-blocking last year than the Texans - so it’s at least worth considering.
I know the Texans were burned by Ahman Green, but that’s different. Green was brought in to be THE guy, the every-down back… I would think LT would only come unless he had a defined role.
Chester Taylor will be 31 in September. That said, he hasn’t exactly been run into the ground the last few years… he’s a proven runner, and very dangerous pass-catching back. I just can’t get into the idea of bringing a guy in who is 31. Thomas Jones seems to be the only guy in recent memory who was able to beat the “Rule of 30″ that RBs seem to have. Maybe if Taylor wouldn’t command a ton of guaranteed money (which he absolutely will) I would consider him. Otherwise, meh.
Darren McFadden is a guy I’ve done a complete 180 on. This time last year I was in favor of making some kind of move (though I knew it was complete fantasy) to procure him from the Raiders. Oakland had shown interest in Andre Davis a couple of years ago, so I was thinking Davis and a couple of picks for McFadden.
Now, I’m over the guy. Sure, he’s only been in the league two years, but when I see him, I see a guy who runs kind of soft. On top of that, he’s been injury-prone, and he has actually had a very solid run-blocking O-line in front of him, with disappointing results.
So, my short answer is - I don’t really like any of them. I’d like for us to address the RB issue in the draft, but if I had to pick a free agent - I’d really be interested in Willis McGahee once the Ravens inevitably cut him this offseason. He’s been pretty durable, and he’s an incredibly decisive one-cut runner. The dude gets downhill FAST - but the reality is, once he is cut he will probably be THE most-wanted FA running back in the league. Someone will pay up big time for him, probably with much more than the Texans would bother with.
Carson said, among other things: Unless they find a quality FA, they’re stuck again with hoping Amobi Okoye “blossoms”.
I get what you’re saying here, Carson. I too am done waiting for Amobi to blossom. I see no reason whatsoever why he will suddenly be the guy we all want him to be. I wouldn’t want to move him around like Kyle has suggested, and I definitely don’t want to wait around hoping he becomes something more. If there’s a guy that plays his position that the Texans think will improve the line - jump on it. If that means cutting Amobi or moving him down the depth chart, fine.
I think Amobi is getting more slack than other players normally would because of how young he was when they drafted him. Well, that’s fine - but to me it’s also a reason not to draft a guy based on how good he is at 18, and how good he MIGHT be at 22. Sure, I think the guy could still turn out to be something special-ish, but I’m ready for the excuses and/or “reasons” for his average play to stop.
Kyle said on the Mock Draft Tracker page: I have been gushing about Toby Gerhart at #80 so often that I’m afraid we as a Texans fan base are showing our hand.
I agreed with a lot of Kyle’s draft prognostications last offseason, but this year he and I aren’t on the same page - now that could change once the Combine is done, but for now, there are two players Kyle is high on that I’m not. One is Stanford RB Toby Gerhart. Yeah, I think he’s a good back and I think he’d be an excellent compliment to Steve Slaton.
My problem is, I don’t want the Texans to draft a complimentary back in this draft. I want them to get a guy who can be an every-down back. I’m going to wait until after the Combine to get into specifics, but I don’t see Gerhart as a guy who could be “Slatonesque” as in they draft him for a certain role and he turns out to be a 20-24 carries per game guy.
Another guy I’m not high on is Brian Price, DT from UCLA. First of all, he’d most likely play Amobi’s position, and like I said I’m not in favor of moving Okoye to a different position. Maybe it’s not so much that I don’t like Price as it is I like other guys more. I’d much rather have Dan Williams at this point, and if the other big-name DTs are off the board, I’d rather go after a guy in the mid-rounds.
The wild card for me in all this DT talk is Terrence Cody. Yeah, he’s a blubbery fat bastard right now at 370 (!!!) but if he shows up lighter at the Combine and has all the measurables, you have to at least consider him. Then again, if he does do well at the Combine and has shed some weight, he probably will shoot back up the draft board and may not be there when the Texans pick. We shall see. It really is just too early for me right now… I generally like to get past the Combine before I start any hard research… and by hard research, I mean collecting other people’s hard research on the Internet.